Articles

S/4HANASAP

Transitioning from ECC to SAP S/4HANA: A strategic imperative for business growth

Learn why migrating to SAP S/4HANA is not just an upgrade—it’s a transformative shift towards smarter operations.

Problem

Change is never simple, but when executed strategically, it can unlock new levels of efficiency, agility, and growth for your business. Migrating to SAP S/4HANA is not just an upgrade—it’s a transformative shift towards smarter operations. By embracing advanced technologies such as real-time data processing, streamlined workflows, and a scalable cloud infrastructure, S/4HANA enables faster, data-driven decision-making, enhanced operational flexibility, and long-term business growth. It’s not just about adopting new software; it’s about positioning your business to thrive in an increasingly digital and competitive landscape.

The business case for SAP S/4HANA

SAP S/4HANA is a strategic shift that turns a business need into a powerful catalyst for innovation. This platform empowers your organization with real-time analytics, integrated processes, and automation, positioning you to stay ahead of competitors and unlock value across your operations.

However, many businesses view the transition to S/4HANA as a compliance-driven requirement due to SAP’s decision to phase out ECC support by 2027. While it’s understandable to view this as an obligation, it’s critical to recognize the opportunities this migration presents.

As PwC notes:

“The sentiment we are hearing in the market is that there is very little appetite for large-scale transformation programs… It’s hard to justify spending $50-100M and disrupting your business for years when there are so many competing priorities.”

The irony is that delaying this transformation may only escalate long-term risks and costs. Without regular updates, security patches, and new features, businesses relying on ECC risk falling behind on critical advancements in areas like cloud integration, AI, machine learning, and advanced analytics. Moreover, the absence of security patches exposes organizations to evolving cyber threats, which could lead to data breaches, compliance violations, and financial losses.

Why SAP S/4HANA matters

SAP S/4HANA is more than just an upgrade—it’s a reimagining of SAP’s ERP technology. Powered by the HANA in-memory database, it streamlines operations by eliminating ERP challenges like manual processes, batch delays, and data fragmentation. The result is enhanced efficiency, reduced IT costs, and faster business processes.

Here’s how SAP S/4HANA improves upon SAP ECC:

  1. Performance & Efficiency
    S/4HANA leverages an in-memory database and columnar data storage, significantly speeding up data retrieval and processing. This architecture supports real-time insights and eliminates batch processing, enabling businesses to make faster, data-driven decisions.

  2. User Experience & Customisation
    The traditional SAP GUI in ECC is replaced with the modern SAP Fiori interface, offering a more intuitive and responsive experience. S/4HANA also promotes best practices by simplifying customisations, reducing dependency on legacy modifications.

  3. Data Model & Integration
    S/4HANA has a simplified data structure with fewer tables, reducing redundancy and boosting efficiency. It integrates seamlessly with emerging technologies like AI, machine learning, blockchain, and IoT, positioning businesses to drive innovation. It also integrates easily with third-party solutions using SAP Business Technology Platform (BTP), which ECC struggles to do.

  4. Deployment Flexibility
    S/4HANA is cloud-native, providing flexible deployment options: on-premises, private cloud, public cloud, or hybrid. This scalability and cloud architecture enable seamless updates, faster scalability, and high availability, making it more adaptable than ECC’s on-premises-only approach.

  5. Cost and Maintenance
    By simplifying processes and automation, S/4HANA reduces IT maintenance costs, while ECC’s complex architecture demands more resources, resulting in higher costs for updates and troubleshooting.

  6. Real-Time Analytics & Reporting
    With real-time data processing, S/4HANA supports immediate analytics and reporting, empowering businesses to make faster decisions. In contrast, ECC requires external tools for comprehensive reporting, slowing down decision-making.

  7. Innovation Enablement
    S/4HANA’s cloud-native architecture is designed to evolve, with regular updates and seamless integration of new technologies like AI, ML, blockchain, and IoT, keeping businesses ahead of the curve. ECC’s legacy system, however, limits adaptability and innovation.

The risks of not migrating

The risks of remaining on ECC are significant and cannot be overlooked:

  • Limited Support and Updates
    ECC support will end by 2027, with extended maintenance available until 2030 at an additional cost. Without regular updates, your system will become increasingly outdated, hindering innovation and putting you at risk of non-compliance.
  • Adapting to Modern Business Needs
    ECC is ill-equipped to handle modern demands such as real-time data processing and digital transformation. As businesses increasingly rely on new technologies, staying on ECC could severely limit your ability to stay competitive.
  • Inefficiency and High Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
    Legacy systems like ECC often create bottlenecks and inefficiencies, relying on slow, batch-driven processes. As competitors adopt advanced technologies integrated with S/4HANA, businesses that delay migration risk falling behind in both operational and strategic capabilities.

Strategic approaches for a smooth S/4HANA migration

To ensure a seamless transition, it’s essential to adopt a migration strategy that fits your organisation’s needs. SAP offers several approaches:

  1. Greenfield Approach
    This approach involves starting fresh with S/4HANA, leaving behind legacy systems and data. Ideal for businesses without complex customisations, it allows a complete reimagining of processes and the adoption of best practices.

  2. Brownfield Approach
    This approach upgrades your existing ECC system to S/4HANA while retaining key elements like customisations, data, and workflows. It’s suitable for businesses that want to preserve existing processes while benefiting from S/4HANA’s new capabilities.

  3. Hybrid Approach
    A combination of the greenfield and brownfield approaches, the hybrid approach allows businesses to migrate specific units or functions to S/4HANA while leaving others on ECC. This offers flexibility and enables a staged transition.

PwC emphasises the need to evaluate the extent of transformation your organisation is ready to embrace. Should you limit it to the Finance function, adopting best practices like the universal ledger and real-time reconciliation? Or should it extend to other areas like procurement and HR? Early answers to these questions are critical to a successful migration.

Our recommendation: The Brownfield Migration approach

We recommend the Brownfield approach, which upgrades your existing ECC system while optimising data and customisations. This method avoids migrating everything as-is and focuses on leveraging S/4HANA’s built-in capabilities, eliminating unnecessary customisations.

For data migration, it’s crucial to clean, review, and optimise your data before the move. By minimising unnecessary complexity and using S/4HANA’s standard functionality, you can lower costs, improve system performance, and create a future-proof ERP foundation.

Best practices for a seamless S/4HANA migration

To ensure a smooth S/4HANA migration, strategic preparation is key. Here’s how to approach it:

  1. Early planning
    Assess your current systems, customisations, and business requirements to create a solid foundation.

  2. Stakeholder engagement
    Involve both IT and business teams early on to ensure alignment of goals and minimise resistance.

  3. Data cleanup
    Streamline your data to reduce complexity and ensure only relevant information is migrated.

  4. Thorough testing
    Develop a comprehensive testing plan to validate processes, check system compatibility, and mitigate risks.

  5. Change management
    Implement a change management strategy to guide employees through the transition and address resistance to new processes.

  6. Training and support
    Offer training to ensure users are fully equipped to leverage S/4HANA’s capabilities.

By preparing strategically, you can make your migration process smoother and more successful. In our upcoming articles, we will dive into the specifics of testing, data migration approaches, and common challenges businesses face during the S/4HANA migration process, along with strategies to overcome them.

Reach New Heights

Modern enterprise is built upon powerful tools. With SAP at the heart of your business, you can not only realise operational efficiencies but also unlock a wealth of intelligence to help drive strategy and success.

Whether you are just beginning your transformation or you’re maturing your existing SAP landscape, we can help you achieve your platform goals faster by assuring quality and accelerating delivery.

Get Updates

Get the latest articles, reports, and job alerts.

AUTHOR:

Sheldon Justin

Senior Consultant - Quality Engineering

Security Center

We use cookies to optimise our site and deliver the best experience. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Please read our Cookie Policy  for more information or to update your cookie settings.